The election of President Obama has done at least one thing to improve the political climate, and that is to put health care front and center as an issue. That’s fortunate, because we have been ignoring multiple parallel crises in the American care system for decades, and the consequences are becoming deadly serious. We spend more than any other country on health care, and we get less for our money than any industrialized nation.
The first problem is under-participation. The AMA has estimated that more than half of Americans do not have their own Primary Care Physicians. Add to that, of course, the more than 50 million Americans with no health coverage at all, and you can see that more than 150 million people in this country are not getting regular checkups, do not have the medical care they do receive coordinated by anybody, have no central store for medical records, have no way to manage the risk of pharmaceutical interaction, are not detecting disease early and are not treating it effectively. We can see the consequences when more than ten percent of our health care costs stem from one disease: Diabetes. Since most diabetes is Type 2, the vast majority of these costs are preventable through early risk identification and lifestyle changes. Instead, we are spending hundreds of billions of dollars to treat people who should never have been sick.
The second problem is the role of profit in the health insurance industry. It’s not simply that thirty percent of our extravagant spending goes to profit and the recision and denial mechanisms necessary to protect it, but the profit motive of employer-based care produces perverse incentives. Care is denied whenever possible. Early intervention is denied to minimize “medical loss,” even though it would reduce future outlays, because insurers do not know if they will cover the patient when they get sicker. They have no incentive to reduce their future costs by eliminating deductibles and co-pays for diagnostic and preventive care. Thus the financial incentives of insurers are perversely related to the health outcomes of their policyholders. Insurers are profitable while Americans become sicker every year.
The third problem has been the least-discussed: the subsidized corn sugars and soy oils that are killing us. The modern epidemics of obesity and diabetes are directly related to the late twentieth-century surge of subsidies into factory farms that produce little but empty calories. Our foods contain steadily diminishing quantities of vitamins, anti-oxidants and amino acids as a giant biochemistry experiment engulfs its third generation. The health consequences of our fast-food culture are so severe that life expectancies are actually beginning to drop.
So, we’re facing a fifty trillion dollar Medicare iceberg at the same time we’re spending tens of billions a year to subsidize the foods that are killing us. But conservatives choose to blame poorly educated working class families with little money and less time for patronizing the businesses these same conservatives spend their time fighting for. The hypocrisy of it would be startling were not hypocrisy the operating standard of the conservative movement. On the one hand, the mounting data linking modern factory food to every form of chronic disease is dismissed as liberal “culture war” against good old-fashioned American food. On the other hand, people who uncritically consume this fare are blamed for the diseases that result. Don’t they know this stuff is bad for you?
All too often, they don’t. Industrial food is huge business in the United States, spending billions of dollars a year to market their products, targeted specifically at younger, poorer people who do not know about the link between the epidemics of diabetes and obesity and the food they are eating. Fast food outlets are located where poorer, less-educated people work, shop and live. Two-income families working three or four part-time jobs with little control over their working hours lack the ability to get together for a home-cooked meal. Even if they could make the time, they find that the fresh fruits and vegetables they need to stay healthy are not subsidized, not as available in their neighborhoods and require a struggle to get small children to eat, a struggle they no longer have the time or energy to undertake. So they get the fried chicken or the Happy Meal and stave off hunger for another day, frequently unaware that these foods are not just vaguely unhealthy but specifically deadly to precisely the kind of poorer, less-educated families the companies that sell them target with their advertisements and store placement.
So, minimum wage workers must show “personal responsibility” but food industry and health insurance executives are allowed, no, required, to cut any corner, tell any lie, spare no expense, walk away from any number of sick and needy people, to make profits that enrich them and their shareholders. If one were to wake up and say to herself “I make money from human misery and basic human decency demands that I stop,” she would be treated as mentally ill and possibly face tort action.
Capitalism is a vital part of modern society and I wouldn’t live in any country without it, but if there are no other values in a society save those of the marketplace, that society is in crisis. We have to stop arguing about the obvious and we have to stop treating corporate interests as if they were inviolate. Our physical and economic futures depend on it. Let’s put single-payer back on the table and justify it by pointing to the fiscal crisis in Medicare. And let’s stop paying Cargill, Monsanto and ADM to make us sick.
#1 by Jerry Axelrod on July 28, 2009 - 7:40 am
Quote
Here, here Rob. You tell a convincing story favoring Health Care Reform. Our problem is not the Republicans, but the so called moderate Democrats who are the whole owned subsidiaries of the Insurance Companies and HMOs. They need to be exposed for their taking millions of dollars from these organizations and failing to protect the public, their true responsiblity. Keep up the good work. Jerry
#2 by Lark Shields on July 28, 2009 - 12:17 pm
Quote
Nice words Rob, but Jerry is exactly correct. It is the Democrats that are not standing up for the American people. When over 70% of Americans want a Public Option (and probably single payer) there is no excuse for the Democrats not to get this done. Now I am hearing there will be no Public Option and Obama is not going to draw a line in the sand. Whom so much for the change we need. You could see a mass exodus next election. Keep trying, but the Dems don’t have the _____ to stand up for the American people it seems to me.
#3 by Kevin on July 28, 2009 - 8:43 pm
Quote
Have you ever read the Constitution of the United States or the Declaration of Independence? Specifically Section 8 of the Constitution which lists 18 “Powers Delegated to Congress” and the 10th Amendment which states, ” The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.” The Federal Government is not the Savior of the country. It has routinely usurped our freedom under the guise of providing safety or entitlement to us poor stupid people who aren’t intelligent enough to live our lives without the Federal Government taking care of us or providing for us.
America is the greatest country in the world as is evidenced by the fact that more people from other countries want to come here than any other country in the world. These immigrant wannabes, think they will find freedom and opportunity here. The freedom to make decisions conserning thier lives and how to raise thier family. The opportunity to succeed based on their own hard work, intelligence, ingenuity, and determination. If they wanted Socialism (Big Daddy Government providing for them cradle to grave), they’d be flocking to Europe. What they will find here is a federal government that controls every aspect of their lives and is operating way outside of its authority as defined in the Constitution. A federal government that punishes those who actually contribute to society by stealing their money and passing it out to a bunch of parasites who do nothing but sponge off the work of others.
I recommend you read our founding documents and spend some time thinking about true freedom which I define as the ability to live my life without government interference, the ability to make decisions for myself and my family, the ability to keep the money I earn from MY labor and distribute it how I decide to distribute it.
#4 by pris on July 30, 2009 - 11:29 am
Quote
Nice rant, Rob. There was an article in the Roanoke Times today that is relevant:
“For the 10th year in a row, a small army of volunteers stepped up last weekend to transform the Wise County Fairgrounds into a free health care clinic for the uninsured and underinsured.
Every year, the numbers seeking treatment grow.
Organizers said most come from the surrounding coal-mining region, but the failure that draws them here once a year is not an Appalachian phenomenon. It’s a national failure of the way America provides health care, a way that must change.”
more here:
http://www.roanoke.com/editorials/wb/213551
#5 by Rob Field on August 5, 2009 - 11:06 pm
Quote
Full disclosure, Kevin is my cousin and former Airborne officer who served multiple tours in Iraq. Welcome to the blog, Kevin.
#6 by Bill on August 7, 2009 - 4:46 pm
Quote
I think Kevin needs to get off the public dole since he’s so self sufficient and quit relying on government provided security (police, fire, military), government provided roads and infrastructure that allow all the goods and services he relies on to be delivered, government provided education, hospitals, etc. True, we should strive to be as self-sufficient as possible and value freedom and hard work, but we’re also a community and should try to find ways of helping those who are down and providing for the common good and security by pooling some resources in the form of taxes to pay for large endeavors.
Health care is very broken when it comes down to a trip to the ER for most people long after they’ve gotten too sick for early, less costly intervention. They don’t ever go to the doctor when it could make a difference because so many people without coverage can’t afford regular preventive care. I just lost my job not long ago and I no longer have employer subsidized health care, except for as long as I can afford the COBRA payments. My partner does not have a job where health care is provided nor did he qualify to be on my healthcare. There’s got to be some more sane way to provide early, regular care for people that is less expensive than what we have now.